AI in Chemistry: Study Highlights Strengths and Weaknesses
Computing power in the chemistry lab: Kevin Jablonka (left) and his team at HIPOLE Jena. Photo: Renzo Paulus
How well does artificial intelligence perform compared to human experts? A research team at HIPOLE Jena set out to answer this question in the field of chemistry. Using a newly developed evaluation method called “ChemBench,” the researchers compared the performance of modern language models such as GPT-4 with that of experienced chemists.
The study has recently been published in the journal Nature Chemistry (DOI 10.1038/s41557-025-01815-x).
More than 2,700 chemistry tasks from research and education were tested—ranging from fundamental knowledge to complex problems. In areas such as reaction prediction or the analysis of large datasets, AI models often excelled with high efficiency. However, a critical weakness became apparent: the models also produced confident answers even when they were factually incorrect. Human chemists, by contrast, were more cautious and questioned their own assessments.
“Our study shows that AI can be a valuable tool—but it is no substitute for human expertise,” says Dr. Kevin M. Jablonka, lead author of the study. The findings offer important insights for the responsible use of AI in chemical research and education.
HIPOLE Jena (Helmholtz Institute for Polymers in Energy Applications Jena) is an institute of HZB in cooperation with Friedrich Schiller University Jena (FSU Jena).
- Thin nickel films boost green hydrogen productionUltra-thin nickel oxide coatings can significantly improve the performance of anion exchange membrane (AEM) water electrolysers, a promising technology for producing green hydrogen. This was demonstrated by a team led by HZB scientist Dr. Michelle Browne. The results show that a nickel oxide film only 10 nanometres thick outperformed conventional nickel oxide powder electrodes while using less than 1% of the catalyst material. The study is published in the Journal of Materials Chemistry A,
- Detailed insights at BESSY II into the oxidation processes of copperBefore pure copper oxide builds up, complex superstructures such as ‘29’CuxO, are formed. The new results on the '29' CuxO superstructure have relevance for catalyst research and corrosion protection in the development of safe copper containers for nuclear waste repositories.
- An important step towards detecting fractons in quantum spin liquidsFollowing predictions of the existence of fractons in quantum spin liquids by more general gauge field theories, researchers at HZB succeeded in detecting these quasi-particles also in a quantum solid-state model.